1- Bewitching Streamine liquid eyeliner pencil Long Lasting & no transfer-resistant waterproof comfortable feeling of grip, black; brand new, never opening (only 1 included, unlike 4th pic) 2- NYX Waterproof Retractable Eyeliner Color MPE02 Black; brand new, never opened ***BUY ONE OR BOTH. PRICE/LISTING IS FOR BOTH 😄