Previously owned but in great condition. Each pair retails for $24 ($48 total). I am selling both pairs together for a great value. The sparkles (cubic zirconia) in Pair 1 are crystal in color. Very classic and timeless. On Pair 2, the sparkles are a rainbow of colors. Beautiful and fun. Note: the cardboard squares shown in the photos are not the original ones that the earrings came on and are not included in the sale. I believe the posts are actually sterling silver, per the description of the item I found on Madewell’s’ website (see photos).