4 rare Ty Beanie Babies

Set of 4 rare Ty Beanie Babies 1 Crunch the shark DOB 1/13/96 Generation 4 swing tag 1 Inky the octopus (pink color) DOB 11/29/94 Generation 4 swing tag Tag has sticker residue see pic 1 Manny the manatee DOB 6/8/95 Generation 4 swing tag 1 Flash the dolphin DOB 5/13/93 Generation 4 swing tag Slight discoloration under chin area I have not attempted to clean