Does have a scuff on right toe as pictured. Price reflects From website: Leather uppers. TOMS leather products support responsible manufacturing via the Leather Working Group. • Stacked leather wrap heel, approximately 2 ¾" • Rubber outsole • High-rebound comfort Ortholite Eco X40 Hybrid insoles made with 32% eco content • Easy slip-on construction • Approx. 23/4" heel SIZING This style fits true to size.