American Eagle black sweater

This black sweater says size L but I'm a size XS/S and I really like the fit. Looking at it I think it really looks more like a S (even M is stretching it). In pretty good condition despite its age (from the early 2000's) and has some very slight pilling, barely noticeable. The design is "inside out" with the seams on the outside. Very cute sweater- good for dressing up or down.