I almost exclusively wear Birks due to a foot condition. I love these but I just am not into black. Worn last winter season. GUC. You can see the shearling bedding has some wear but still plenty of fluff. There is a hard spot inside the right shoe bed close to where your pinky toe would hit--I didn't know it was there until I went to clean them. I have never felt it while wearing. Soles are in great shape, and outside top is very good. A little wear to the sides. Will ship next day.