Oh how I ADORE THESE satin pumps with a bow on the side. I bought them in 2011 and wore them ONCE in the photos seen. Thed 4-3/4" heel is too high for my weak ankle and they slipped a bit on my heal, so I'd say they'd ALMOST fit a 9.5, but definitely a larger 9 or a 9 with a gel insert, would probably be best. I wish I thought of that. I adore them. I just can't wear them or any of my heels really, sadly. :( Anyway. These are gorgeous dressed up or down and have minor wear on the leather sole and no visible wear on the inner sole. I see a mark on the back of the right heel... which I'm thinking arrived that way considering I can see it in the photos of me wearing them back in 2011 and I haven't worn them (before or since) - honestly, I love having my blog as a virtual closet, see the post here https://lovemaegan.com/dont-say-words-youre-gonna-regret-dont-let-the-fire-rush-to-your-head/