Basically new! I purchased these from BHLDN for my wedding but ended up going with one of the other 3 pairs I purchased (it was a tough decision)! Worn minimally while I was trying to make my decision. The left heel has a small scuff on it. They came that way and I didn’t care about it enough to return them. It’s on the inside so really doesn’t show when you’re wearing them. You can see it in the pictures. I’m a pretty solid size 8, and I would say these run true to size.