Cleaning Paste - Pink Stuff Knockoff I buy this from Dollar Tree for $1.25+tax. You can too! It's also avail at Wallmart online.. For $9!!!! Don't buy it at Wallmart!!! I can get you what you need..if you need. I use it for any and all tarnish. Both silver and gold, real and tone. **Disclaimer ** I am not a chemist. Use at your own risk. This is based on my own experience as a seller and over 20+ years in cleaning and janitorial business experience.