Purchased at TJ Maxx (obviously from the tags lol) but I bought them as an option for an outfit and they didn’t work out. There is a small spot that is weird on the toe of the left shoe. I tried to take a picture of it as best I could. It’s been there since I purchased them. It’s not a stain? But it’s like there is a small part of the fabric/threading was a different color? They’re still super cute!