J Crew Penney Loafer

I just recently purchased these at J Crew. I can't remember the actual color, but they are a caramel in color. They are a true penney loafer with a 1/2" heel. I wore these once, and they were a little tight. I realized that is because I bought an 8. I am an 8.5. However, I have Lupus, so I buy a size 9 due to inflammation. So, I goofed. They are scuffed on the toe bed because I wore them once outside. Otherwise, like new. I have the box.