Laundry room switchplate cover

Just received a switchplate cover I had made, but as you can see from 2nd to last pic, its smaller than my existing cover (last pic). Wouldn't cover the raw sheetrock edges around electrical box 😣 I LOVE the graphic and saying...adds a whimsical touch to the "fun" laundry room. This switchplate measures: 2.5" W x 4.5" H. Comes in original packaging, with custom painted screws to match graphic..never used.