"From Kate Spade New York, the Gardner Street Platinum Butter Plate is crafted of durable white bone china with precious platinum accents. This stylish and versatile dish is dishwasher-safe." This is a set of four (4) butter plates. Two of the plates are new with tags, the other two do not have tags. These butter plates would be considered "seconds" as there are some minor imperfections in the platinum accents, as pictured. I have circled the imperfections in blue.