Lorca front of the pro eye pencils Black & Bronze

I tried on the black two times and didn't like how it turned out. I only swap the bronze one time. Pretty much new on bronze and pretty good condition on black. The sharper (the end spot) for the bronze broke when I tried to open it. The black one is fine which you can see on the photo. $31 for both eyeliners! Original price was $20 each. I passed the rerun date so I can't return them anymore.