Purchased while traveling, new in-store in September 2024, never wore out and decided to return, but couldn't without the box (which I didn't pack onto the airplane)! No flaws, never worn, with little tree and padding intact inside. Often sell out in smaller sizes. Black leather. From website: Greta is back. Our best-selling leather ballet flats have a perfectly squared-off toe, an elastic Mary Jane strap and dozens of five-star reviews. Plus, our MWL Cloudlift Lite padding makes it feel like you're walking on a...well, you know. We heard you, Greta fans: an early version of this shoe had a faulty lining that has been fixed for all new shipments. Please note: this item will naturally stretch for a roomier fit, so we recommend ordering a half size smaller than your normal size. Some wrinkling and buckling may occur due to the unlined construction. Leather upper. Leather lining. Man-made sole. Do Well: leather sourced from a tannery that was certified by the Leather Working Group (LWG), an organization that works to promote sustainable environmental practices in the leather industry.