NWOT -American Eagle ankle strap flats - size 8.5

PLEASE READ: These satin flats have never been worn outside - only around the house to see if they fit.......however they run small & just do not fit my feet comfortably, like my usual size does. They are size 8.5 but I usually wear a size 8-8.5 so I would classify them as a size 7.5. Somehow they have managed to get two small spots on them just from sitting in my closet (as seen in last pic). These are adorable shoes & would be a great find for the right size, so please make me an offer!