These were used for a few years during our shoulder seasons (think rain-snow-mud season). I scrubbed them up but you can see bit of the dirt held onto the front black exterior. Each sole has slight wear on the back outer edge (see closeup photo of rear sole). They still look great but it’s time for a change. I wear a women’s 10 and these fit well. The original insoles are in the boots. When I was trying to decide if I wanted to keep these, I trimmed new altra insoles to match the sorel ones. I’ll send those with the boot in case you want to use those.