T.U.K Viva Mondo Black Leather Shoes NIB fit like 4.5

From the T.U.K. site (https://www.tukshoes.com/products/black-leather-viva-mondo-creepers): "These black leather T.U.K. Viva Mondo Creepers feature the new lightweight and more flexible soles in our traditional 1 7/8" Mondo height. These creepers have a black woven interlace, and silver metal D-rings." These are adorable, but fit more like a 4.5 even though they are marked as a size 5. The toe box is pretty narrow. Originally bought them on here for $70. They are in brand new condition and perfect for the first day of school.