Valentino Rockstud Kitten Heel Black Size 9.5/39.5

Purchased in May of 2016 from Nordstrom. These were loved- see picture for small scuff in front of left toe and leather scuff mark on left heel. Sole and bottom of shoe have normal wear on inside and outside (see pictures). Comes with original box and dust bag. I love these but they are a half size too small, I tried squeezing in them but it just wont work :( I am usually a size 9. These fit snug, better for a size 8.5 or even an 8 potentially in non-designer shoes.