These shoes look absolutely brand new. I don't see scuffs or any signs of wear besides a scuff on the sole and black sharpie marks on the soles. See photos. These are made for a serious baddie!!! They're too high for me to feel confident that I won't break an ankle. But I'm someone who wears heels less than once a year. The front of the shoe has a platform base, so they're more comfortable than you'd think.