I am on a perpetual hunt for my perfect one neutral eye palette. I love Victoria Beckham eye liners so I gave this one a shot but it’s too dark for me. I tried the two end colors barely and haven’t even touched the darker two in middle It just arrived today and they don’t accept used returns so my loss is your gain - this is for the compact (which is very solid and pretty ) and the shadow palette. They arrived separately. I have the boxes but I’ll prob leave the shadow in the compact to keep it safer